In the top right, click Settings Settings – the Cogg
Now in the GMail search box enter something like this:
after:2009/1/1 before:2017/1/1 is:unimportant OR is:notstarred
Next select the tick at the top of the column – I’ll labeled in 1 in red below.
Followed by clicking on “Select all messages that match this search” – I’ll labeled in 2 in red below.
Click on the Bin icon:
And then you can finally delete on the not important not starred email between the time period you selected! By OKing the “Confirm bulk action” delete!
Then go back to settings as above and Enable “Conversation View” on
Finally navigate to your labels on the left hand side, go down to "more" then "Bin", select all, delete and hopefully find thousands of emails to completely remove from GMail.
If you don’t do the final Bin purge below they will all still get completely deleted by GMail in the next 30 days from when you did the purge!
For me this was 27,858….